reviewed: You're Wrong About
A favorite
One of my favorite podcasts. It's well written, researched, and commentary from Sarah and her guests is entertaining. I cherish the early episodes with Michael and enjoy the guests in newer episodes.
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Pointless
Very poorly researched. No surprise from huff post writers. Cat nip for cat ladies. Invite an actual expert on a particular topic and discuss with them on said topic. The host are unable to form an a legitimate question or argument. The back and forth is typical huffy posty takes.
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Masturbatory Wikipedia drivel
Get over yourself. I imagined you editing the “anniversary” episode of fake crying listeners and nearly puked. You’re no longer the precocious child you claim to be in nearly every episode. It’s time to grow up and stop whining.
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Yikes
I listened to several episodes to give it a fair shot, but I barely made it through those. The host comes off as stuck up and elitist. She bashes the police, men, psychologists, etc. and speaks as if she truly believes she knows more than those professionals. When she has guests, it just sounds like a conversation between two high school mean girls talking about how they're so superior to everyone else. No actual substance or accurate information at all.
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Still fantastic
The recent negative reviews all have something in common — an aversion to the trans content. We can all read between the lines and tell what these reviewers really mean, and I honestly doubt whether any of them were listeners all along. You’re probably just ending up on some kind of transphobic blog posts or something and it’s bringing out the losers. Keep on keepin on, Sarah and Carolyn. Y’all are fantastic and have made some of my favorite episodes lately. I pay-subscribed specifically for the Fleetwood Mac ep and haven’t been disappointed! Happy to give you my money :)
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Bring on the “liberal activism”!
I never review podcasts. Ever. But the recent low star reviews of YWA made me pause. Why the change? Why is it somehow upsetting to folks that Sarah is delving into topical issues with guests who are part of marginalized communities? I say bring it on! I am a cis white woman and I am excited to learn more about the current attacks on trans folks from actual trans folks. Keep doing good work, Sarah!
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Lack of nuance
The lack of nuance is intellectually dishonest and isn’t helpful to anyone..
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Inceptionnn
I kind of like the reviews when Sarah Marshall gets something wrong (or doesn’t, but always blame a woman) and people get mad bc…isn’t that the point? That sometimes you’re wrong about something? Let’s talk about it. And that’s just like, your opinion, man. 🦑👯♂️🔥🍇 -current holder of 5 college degrees (the real kind), and current(read: forever)felon. Guess which of these things matter. This show makes me feel like I still matter. Thank you for that.
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
great new ep!!
loved the episode with tuck about the NYT! the best breakdown of this issue i’ve seen yet and a great opportunity to give tuck (certifiably an expert) a platform!
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Anna Nicole Smith
You need to tackle this. Only you guys can do it justice. Her Netflix doc was repulsive
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Way downhill
This show used to be pretty great. It’s devolved into an intellectually lazy rap session in which Sarah Marshall and her guest offer half-baked ideas and slag off journalists while casually dropping cringe-inducing logical fallacies. It’s essentially become two teenagers sitting in a basement talking about how superior they are to their classmates, not realizing that no one wants to hang out with them because they’re insufferable and mean-spirited.
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Intersexed
Why aren’t physiological “hermaphrodites” or intersexed people ever included in gender justice? I’ve always been curious about that. I feel they are being left behind, completely invisible. Honestly, I’m perplexed by it and can’t seem to get over it😬
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Journalist or activist?
This show has become nothing more than progressive activism. I feel like Sarah used to make an attempt to be more objective and explore gray areas and nuance. Now she has activist guest hosts on and says that you shouldn’t be allowed to question anyone’s radical ideology. That you shouldn’t even be allowed to ask why so many teens are suddenly identifying as trans, and why they are being rushed into medical interventions and surgery. I am officially done with this podcast.
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
That’s not what an Alford Plea
Maybe this podcast was better researched in the beginning but I was floored at the inaccurate and bias description of an Alford plea. I had to unfollow. It made me distrust the information shared on topics that I am less knowledgeable on. There’s plenty wrong with the justice system so maybe talk about those things instead of hyping distrust for something that’s simply not a problem?
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Really?!
Latest episode is incredibly bad. And narrow minded. And. . . full of logical fallacies. I can’t even. Oh my goodness.
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Liberal propaganda
You (hostess) and your ignorance are what is wrong with this world. This podcast used to be somewhat informative. Emphasis on “somewhat” Conservatives and republicans will be annoyed if they listen to this actual trash. Unfollowed
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
The power of YWA
A flight attendant on Southwest gave me free drink tickets because she saw that I was listening to the Princess Diana episodes.
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Missing Michael :(
Unsubscribing, the podcast really lost its structure. I used to adore the episodes and thought-provoking frameworks. With just Sarah, the perspectives feel one-dimensional and more recently, uninformed and even careless. Getting some facts wrong is okay but the understanding of the Channel Miller/Brock Turner case was thoughtless and connecting it to the restorative justice model is deeply unconscionable in my mind. I always had a sense Michael researched topics to the best of his ability to unpack them, I’m not getting that any more from Sarah.
Reviewed on Apple Podcastsreviewed: You're Wrong About
Love love love
Absolutely love. Sarah is such a joy to listen to and her insights always hit it on the head for me.
Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Mike and Sarah are journalists obsessed with the past. Every week they reconsider a person or event that's been miscast in the public imagination.
Tagged with
History
Tagged with
History