When Diplomacy Fails Podcast

When Diplomacy Fails Podcast

Published by: Zack Twamley
516 Episodes | First Released: May 18 '12

A weekly podcast covering the build up to, breakout of and consequences of various conflicts in history.

Label
Douglas Hulkhater
Sep 18
Rating:   10
I used to think history was boring

Zach has such a pleasant voice and makes history really facinating. I listen on the way home from work to wind-down.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Jimmy S is laughing
Aug 8
Rating:   10
Very Impressive! Not the usual history stories.

I love history and know a lot of history, but Zack brings incredible research and a new perpsective on each topic. I've learned so much. My favorite is the July Crisis on the lead up to WWI. I was totally in the Germans started it end of story camp when I started the podcast. But the day by day events and sources that Zack brings have enabled me to see how complex the realy story is.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
EddieMik88
Jul 19
Rating:   10
Great Podcast

Every episode is well constructed and informative, very entertaining as well. My only complaint is that sometimes the host almost seems to have the mic on his lips because every p, t, b, or other hard consonant sounds like they're going to blow out my speakers.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Grapeape Jim
May 28
Rating:   10
Excellent job

I have really enjoyed this podcast. The writing is clear concise and somehow not boring. This is excellent history.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
TBCarls
Apr 23
Rating:   10
Love the podcast

The host is so prolific, it is hard to keep up. He has even come up with a unique way for the listener to get up close and personal with the historical subject. I still have a lot to learn and I think I want to learn it from Zack Twamley.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Damian4776
Mar 29
Rating:   10
One of the best

I stumbled on this podcast and I’m so glad I do. I know this podcast isn’t for everybody but Zach brings a point of view and a narrative that I have not encountered anywhere else. I love the style, the cadence of his voice and all the detail this podcast goes into.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
BWarnock
Mar 26
Rating:   10
Great take on history

Focusing on diplomacy is a way of looking at history from a different perspective. Zach finds his voice about 25 episodes in. His remasters episodes are fantastic.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
wmark63
Mar 11
Rating:   10
It’s fun

I heard Zach first on History of England and followed him to his own podcast. I have listened to a lot of them over a short period of time and have been really impressed.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
sneferuplz
Feb 12
Rating:   10
Great podcast!

A great podcast that illuminates all the wonderful bankroll dealing and politics that goes into diplomatic relations. Highly recommend the July Crisis, Easter Rising, the Korean War and the current Versailles Anniversary project

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
matt_h84
Jan 22
Rating:   10
Top tier

This is one of the most well researched and entertaining podcasts out there

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
dgetzin
Dec 31 '18
Rating:   10
An innovator in the field

This is a groundbreaking podcast, and not only does it have some of the most thorough and interesting history content there is, Zack's bookending of WW I with the July Crisis and his Versailles series is a scholarly effort with a poetic elegance. The "day by day" production is a real breakthrough and is very moving. He does not shy away from revisionist historiography WHERE NEEDED, which is exactly what should always be done. Myself having been given the "it's complicated" answer to who started WW I in my own high school history class, I was very surprised to hear that across the Atlantic, the "Gerries did it all!" explanation was still considered gospel by serious people. But such controversy is perfect grist for a great podcast. The balance of narrative and analysis here is so finely tuned as to be seamless in an interesting way. Carlin, while untouchable in his singular genius, does tend to shift between narration and analysis modes in his presentation. Someone like Mike Duncan will do narrative only, and do it very well, and then write a paper book of analysis. Zack manages to get analytic in a way that overlays narrative continuously and therefore lets those even totally unfamiliar with a topic keep up, while even experts will find a perspective worth hearing. I felt as much at home in the WW I store of which I knew a lot, as I did in the Anglo Dutch Wars series, of which I knew next to nothing going into it. This scholar demonstrates the benefits of the best academic rigor without ever being blunted by the smallness of intellectual ambition or over-caution that pervades so much of "respectable" history. This is well-worth a listen, and if we don't destroy our civilization too badly in times ahead, I think people will be listening to this podcast 200 years from now. These words and ideas run that deep.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Curteousjonesjr
Dec 29 '18
Rating:   8
Pretentious But Good

Aside from the early audio issues (seems standard for start ups)Twamley’s “I am not gonna talk about battles, this is diplomacy” stance is a little annoying. Not a play-by-play, but battles inform the diplomatic situation. He doesn’t come across as likable but the info is good, and I don’t mind malcontents.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
KindaKyle
Dec 12 '18
Rating:   10
First Among Equals

If you’re only going to subscribe and listen to one podcast then When Diplomacy Fails need to be that podcast.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
CleverRecords
Dec 11 '18
Rating:   4
Come on

I expect a history show to know the difference between “communism vs democracy” rather than “communism vs capitalism.”

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Nochangetoolate
Jul 26 '17
Rating:   2
Regret

This is the first time I am writing a negitive review, which is something I deeply regret. It is difficult to create something and all too easy to criticise.On the good side, this podcast is well produced,well researched and the narrator's voice is pleasent and easy to listen to.Now for the bad. The 1916 Easter Rising mini series. Zack, the narrator flagged well in advance that he held a very negitave and revisionist view of that event. Fair enough, I was prepared to hear a ballanced reasoned account of those events. Unfotunately Zack is neither ballanced of reasonable in his attitude. He omitted several facts which were relevant to events. For instance there was no mention of the Bachelor's Walk massacre which was a pivotal event that occured before the Rising.For me the final straw was in episode 9 when Zack says "At that time every Irishman was entitled to vote ". This is a terrible misleading statment.Men over a property theshold of a certain wealth could vote, about 15% of the Irish adult population in 1916. The other 85% had either not enough money or no right to vote. Mostly full sufferage was enacted in 1918, mostly as some women were still excluded.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Ciaran the Dart Driver
Oct 4 '16
Rating:   10
Best Podcast Ever

Hey I'm new to podcasting but when I stumbled across this one I could not stop listening to every episode! I'm very interested in the Franco Prussian war era and really enjoyed that episode. The Talk episodes are a really nice break between the gritty stuff and really help me to take in all the information. Thanks for the lessons and I hope there are a lot more to come!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Shane L the Merry
Jun 19 '16
Rating:   10
Mr

Fantastic podcast with incredible detail and good delivery. The chat podcasts have made me laugh aloud in public - great stuff :D History of the pre-World War I July Crisis is a highlight.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
JosephS1
May 28 '15
Rating:   10
A must for history podcast fans

I recently came across this pod and it’s fantastically well researched, and I say that as someone with an MA in History. Zack navigates and narrates us tremendously well through some of most pivotal and intriguing moments in history getting the balance spot on between facts and narrative.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Georgathon
Mar 21 '15
Rating:   10
Brilliant

I came across this podcast recently and have flown through the episodes Each episode offers something diverse and interesting and I've learned much about wars and leaders I wouldn't have otherwise It's talk episode are a favourite of mine and as a fellow Irish poor student of history I was delighted to find this podcast Zach your podcast are on par with mike Duncan and Lars brownesworth in my opinion Please keep up the hard work!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Andrew Cooper 2013
Aug 10 '13
Rating:   10
Great Work

I've been listener for about a year now, and the WDF podcast is one of my favorite podcasts out there. While the episodes are standalone, together they help to build up a picture of the political scene in various eras that I'd known little about. Keep it up Zack!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
0:00 / 0:00