The Rock Star & The Nanny Podcast

The Rock Star & The Nanny Podcast

Published by: The Rock Star & The Nanny
9 Episodes | First Released: Apr 3 '19
A rock star, a murdered nanny and FIVE suspects… In 1991, Penny Hill was found brutally bashed on the side of a road in Coolah, NSW. She had just landed a dream job as a nanny for Col Baigent – a former drummer with Billy Thorpe and the Aztecs - and his wife Barbara. Three days after starting work, Penny was left for dead in a ditch. This podcast delves into a shocking crime uncovering new evidence into a case that has haunted a community for almost three decades Who killed Penny Hill?
Label
Ajbuda
Aug 2 '19
Rating:   2
About 12 min of new info each show

The first at least 7 min of each episode is review. Along with at least another 2-5 min during the show being replay of previous audio. Probably a total of 1 hour of information divided into the podcasts. Also, it seems more of a report than an investigation. More reading and playing if previous people’s work instead of trying to rely on their on investigating. And the reporting they do Donos trash. ‘Such and such was accused of stalking by an ex’. Not charged or anything, no interview of the accuser, nothing. Trash. Holy crap. Episode five moves their reporting from trash to irresponsible. I hope these people aren’t really reporters in AUS. Wow. My rate went from 4 to 3 to 1. I’d really like to know more about this story, unfortunately, you won’t find it here.Wow. Episode 6 they give key info they had the whole time that changes a bunch of what you thought you knew. Not sure what their point was to do this, unless it was to make the reporters look incredibly clueless. If that was the aim, the nailed it. And then later on it the episode they prove how daft they are. They want to focus on some one who wasn’t even a suspect until one of the CURRENT SUSPECT says she saw a car that doesn’t even really look like his. There is zero even circumstantial evidence. And they keep bringing up this stalking BS that sounds like his ex was a gfs house that didn’t like him, and when he tried to talk to her the gf called the cops. They didn't even talk to the ex. This was such a horribly researched and investigated True Crime podcast.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
PinkPotato💗🥔
May 29 '19
Rating:   2
W O W.

I saw this and was instantly hooked.Then I listened...W O R S T P O D C A S T E V E REpisodes take forever to arrive, clunky intro, useless segments, too many recaps, kinda boring.DON’T LISTEN

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
ACHLC
May 22 '19
Rating:   6
Meh

I’m interested in the story and am hoping that a resolution can be found for the family.....but each episode is so repetitive and where is episode 4?! It’s been weeks. Seems that the entire thing could have been covered in a one hour ep.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Edith01010101
May 22 '19
Rating:   2
Too repetitive

It felt like half of each episode was a recap of the previous episode and the introduction was far too long. Otherwise an interesting case.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Starz 955
May 21 '19
Rating:   4
Episode 4

Still waiting for Episode 4 ???

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Addicted to crime
May 21 '19
Rating:   6
Disappointed

Have to agree with other listeners ...Eps 2 & 3 just regurgitated what we heard in 1...had great potential.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
staria83
May 20 '19
Rating:   10
Finally!

I have been waiting for years for someone to cover this case properly. I hope it gets justice for Penny!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
loveagoodmurder
May 19 '19
Rating:   8
Interesting case, keeps playing in my mind

Needs to be shorter introduction, and the cop is hard to handle as he wouldn’t say anything so why have him?? But such a sad and horrible case. I keep thinking about it. Please bring on the next episode.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
summie53
May 19 '19
Rating:   8
Where is episode 4

Very good podcast, but over waiting for episode 4.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
DCI Ryan
May 17 '19
Rating:   6
Interesting but the narrative needs work.

Like all previous reviews it takes way too long to get to the new information in the next episode. I don’t want to listen to all the previous information at the beginning of each episode again. Get to the facts!!! I want to solve this case!!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
heyvick282
May 17 '19
Rating:   10
Where is it?

Where is episode 4 etc?What is the hold-up?

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Kiwisuzi
May 11 '19
Rating:   6
Recap to long!

I had to look twice to see if I was on the right episode because there was too much re capping. Spoilt the podcast.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
gotabeaf
May 9 '19
Rating:   6
Good but could be better

Great podcast and hope the story gains traction. Please take on feedback however to stop the replays of interviews at the start of the episodes. Too repetitive!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Maxtopia
May 9 '19
Rating:   2
Sooo repetitive

Kept thinking I was accidentally listening to the same episode again

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Janet Straper (from the US)
May 2 '19
Rating:   6
Repetitive filler content

Too much filler content that is recycled from previous episode. Could have easily made fewer episodes with greater impact.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
marilynvank
Apr 27 '19
Rating:   4
Repetitive

Five minutes into a 20 minute episode and all I’ve heard is replays of stuff that’s already been said in the previous two episodes. That combined with the presenter’s closed questions and/or leading questions - yeah nah.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
wajamiandara
Apr 25 '19
Rating:   6
No to the cop.

Really interesting subject, however, if the cop is going to be a big part of the podcast, I don’t think I can continue to listen. Inarticulate and boring.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Chatsy magoo
Apr 17 '19
Rating:   10
Outstanding !

Hope this helps the family and police to move closer to an arrest love the podcast

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Arti G
Apr 12 '19
Rating:   10
Thank you!

So important to get Australian stories out there. Thanks so much for this podcast. So heartbreaking, hope this helps the family in some way and really feel for the woman who found Penny Hill.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
brvndon96
Apr 12 '19
Rating:   10
Gripping!

Mary Ann Harris has delivered an incredibly gripping start to a fascinating case. I cannot wait for the next episodes to arrive. Hoping we get to find out what really happened.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
0:00 / 0:00