1 Episode | First Released: Oct 12
Label
Purplefang
Dec 11
Rating:   10
A+

Well put together show. I love the suspense that isn’t followed by a grisly homicide. Very entertaining

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
FreckwracklerSupreme
Dec 11
Rating:   10
This is a wonderful podcast

Thank you for making this podcast it is a joy to listen to

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Swankybird
Dec 10
Rating:   10
I LOVE this

It’s like if the Black Tapes and Welcome to Nightvale had a baby. The stories are interesting and personable, while still raising the hairs on your arm. Rainn Wilson is hilarious, wonderful, and incredibly talented. It’s awesome!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Ms. Pinto
Dec 10
Rating:   10
On the EDGE of my seat!!!!

Love love this podcast I sit at work for 8hrs a day and this podcast makes me stay AWAKE! I listen to many podcast but never left a review until now!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
MsPixx
Dec 10
Rating:   10
Really fun podcast

Love this podcast. Rainn Wilson is a hilarious host and the stories are super interesting and well told. I’ve been binging this at work today and am sad there are only 7 episodes so far! Definitely going to be one of my weekly listens.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Abby P Indy
Dec 10
Rating:   10
Creepy and so amazing

This podcast will give you the creeps and keep you up at night. I love it and it has me screaming sometimes like when you are watching a movie and you see a ghost creeping on someone. Keep up the good work! I am savoring every episode and trying not to listen to them all at once but it’s addicting!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
HungryEars
Dec 10
Rating:   10
Great story telling!

The intros are very cheesy, but if you can survive the first few minutes you’ll be rewarded by spooky spine tingling stories with awesome audio.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
CaliA.
Dec 10
Rating:   10
Thanks Office Ladies

I heard of this podcast from The Office Ladies podcast. I love it! That’s all. It’s a great listen and entertaining as hell.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Neville198765
Dec 10
Rating:   10
My favorite!

I wish there were a hundred more episodes. Prefer this over music on my drives to work. Such good content.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Carly Keeley
Dec 10
Rating:   10
Great for a road trip

I came across this looking for podcasts to listen to on my way to Kansas City. After the first episode I was hooked. I wish there was more!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Ashjowill
Dec 10
Rating:   10
A little creepy and scary...😳

This podcast is great! It’s like a podcast version of unsolved mysteries - a little creepy and scary but the stories are so interesting you can’t stop listening. I listened to the first episode while driving home. It was already dark and rainy and as I’m getting closer to home, a thick fog settled over the roads - one of those creepy fogs where you can barely see 10 feet in front of you but there are small gaps where you can see. I’m listening to the second half of the podcast at this point (404 Not Found) and as the narrator is describing the photos he’s getting of a person leaving one state to enter the next, I’m slowing driving through this creepy fog. I get to my house and I start to back into the driveway (I have Costco supplies to unload) and I see a movement in my rear camera. I can’t tell what it is because there’s water on it making it unclear. Needless to say I was totally freaked out and trying to figure out what was out there. Now there’s movement in front of me but I’m not seeing it super clearly - at this point I’m sure that someone is trying to get me (while still knowing it’s all in my head and I’m worked up over this story lol). Finally I get a good look at my stalker...Ryder...my neighbor’s Burmese mountain dog who is the just the sweetest. This entire scenario reminded me of watching unsolved mysteries late at night when I was in my early teens and managing to scare the crap out of my self lol.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
AmandaaPacee
Dec 10
Rating:   10
Soooo good

Episode 4 had me like 😱😬😲😵

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
EllieBellie10
Dec 9
Rating:   10
New favorite podcast

Love this! Please keep up the amazing stories. These give me goosebumps

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
juliapdxx
Dec 9
Rating:   10
DWIGHT

He calms me down after each tape lol. This is definitely spooky and gives u full body chills

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
blah31blah25blah
Dec 9
Rating:   10
Awesome

Seriously gave me chills. PLEASE GIVE US MORE!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
ltdonath
Dec 9
Rating:   10
Podcast of the year!!

Exactly what I’ve been looking for in a podcast! This podcast is executed to perfection!!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Siegresto
Dec 9
Rating:   10
Episode 4

Oh. my. God. Goosebumps so big they hurt!!!!!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Doria N.
Dec 9
Rating:   10
Give Me More!

I loooove this podcast! Amazingly, despite thousands of podcasts to sift through and listen to there nothing at all like this podcast. It is riveting interesting and 100% original. I am really hoping there are many more seasons to come in the future. A+++++! Excellent work!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
kevjg
Dec 9
Rating:   10
Binged this in a week.

Heard about this from the Office Ladies podcast and decided to give it a shot. Love this! It’s like a modern twilight zone, but true stories! Some stories are creepy and some are just strange. All of it is entertaining and you have to love Rainn Wilson’s input as the quirky video store clerk.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
t_newman4444
Dec 9
Rating:   10
Okay, LOVE

Payne Lindsey and crew have a way with captivation. You just find yourself hooked and needing more stories//information//answers. Also, Rainn Wilson is a GIANT plus. 11/10 :)

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
0:00 / 0:00