twitter instagram facebook link thumbsup hashtag delete
Info Episodes Discussion Reviews
    Label
    7
    Label
    Finch-nest
    Jun 21
    2

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Wow, ultra woke

    I was excited to finally listen to the beloved podcast. First episode I listen to specifically criticizes someone as a “white man.” Not describes, but criticizes. Sorry MFM, I was born this way. It doesn’t make me evil.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    Bthird
    Jun 20
    10

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Loving MFM

    This podcast is still amazing! They hilarious as always and love each story they bring to each podcast. Been seeing so many review how they’re getting “too political” when that’s not the case at all, and what’s wrong with saying Black Lives Matter and talking about issues that have been affecting minorities? Any who, can’t wait till I can go to one of their live shows!

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    Grown-up lol
    Jun 20
    10

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Addicted!

    I canNOT get enough of these women! Their humor! The random conversations! And of course the murders!

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    jandace
    Jun 20
    6

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Used to be better

    Used to be five stars but what’s with all the constantly recycled content!!! Quilt episodes? Seems like the effort to put up new cases and content has been lacking since I started listening years ago......

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    podcast lover10
    Jun 20
    10

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    amazing podcast!!!!

    I found this podcast around 2 years ago and have been hooked ever since! Toward the beginning I would skip past the chit chat but now I love listening to it, the details make it so much more personal and Karen and Georgia feel like my cool older sister that I get to hang out with

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    $&&?($$;;
    Jun 20
    4

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Went downhill

    I used to love this show it was so good but honestly since they have their new network they have become so lazy and the show is boring! They either play old shows or the horrible live episodes that Are not fun unless you are there in the audience. Disappointed.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    estewwy
    Jun 20
    2

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Should be titled Ramble On

    They just talk about completely unrelated garbage for over half the podcast! I’ve tried so hard to like this podcast but it’s terrible! They should cut the background conversations in half and it would be good.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    Av8trx
    Jun 19
    10

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    It’s a gem!

    Although murder is terrible and horrific, I still love to hear the stories and Karen

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    LCMartini
    Jun 19
    10

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    An all-time great

    Been listening since year one. And will be with the girls (and SRM) till the end. Entertaining, funny, and yes political. But for those that see it as a negative, I’m not sure you’re really listening. These ladies have brought attention to so many of important issues. Thank your Karen, Georgia and the entire Exactly Right network for the work you do. SSDGM.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    taniii2264
    Jun 19
    4

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Miss old content

    I have been a listener for 4 years. Tuned in every week excited for the stories and humor. For the past few months I have stopped tuning in weekly due to the lack of new content. Lots of repeat episodes and I don’t love that both hosts opening admit to doing none of their own research. Often both Karen and Georgia will admit to not knowing what their story is about until the last minute. It comes off as lazy. They make it seem like they hardly pay attention to their platform and make their staff create all content for them. Tired of hearing episodes off topic from true crime and live episodes/repeats. Bring the pizazz back. Still subscribed because my fingers are crossed they will bounce back.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    Go laxbrah
    Jun 19
    6

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Where is the story?

    It would help so much to have time stamps of when you get to the ACTUAL story.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    swaggermcswagger696969
    Jun 19
    2

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Lack of research

    After listening to half an hour of the podcast about them literally talking about thanksgiving (a holiday that was literally about massacring the indigenous peoples) I listened to one episode about a case I am very familiar on, the starlight tours, and they got almost every fact about the case incorrect and rushed through important details. This podcast is trash and I would give it no stars if I could. I would recommend the Canadian true crime version of this story because it’s factual and they don’t skip over details.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    Lo1217
    Jun 18
    10

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    I’m hooked!

    This is the best podcast EVER. Georgia and Karen make such a great pair. They are so funny and down to earth. I can listen to them for hours and do! If you love true crime and have a sense of humor then this podcast is for you.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    Betty Buddy
    Jun 18
    2

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Infuriating to listen to

    Girls, you are just not as interesting as you think you are. I was so frustrated listening to you go on about yourselves for 10 minutes that at that point I just turned you off. Your use of the word “like” for every other word and your obnoxious California inflections were more than I could take.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    chlo2356
    Jun 18
    4

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Too much chat at the start…

    Waaaay too much chat at the start, that isn’t what people came to listen to…other than this the actual podcast is good, when they got onto it!

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    Bschusterrrrrrr
    Jun 17
    10

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    The best

    My favorite podcast (and only podcast I’ve consistently listened to for the past few years) love yall :)

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    jlp_1
    Jun 17
    2

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Just post re-runs and old live shows now

    Used to be good but now they don’t put out any new episodes and just post old recorded live episodes. Absolute trash

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    eab4253
    Jun 17
    6

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Bummer review to write

    This used to be one of my favorite podcasts. Funny, empowering and fantastic storytelling. But then it slowly started getting more and more political until the comments and generalizations about groups of people and regions of the country (that they proudly say they will never go on tour to) kind of took my interest away from the show. If you’re going to preach not stereotyping and being kind, that should also include people who have different beliefs than you. The quality of the episodes has decreased too. Seems less casual and more forced. It feels very “get in and get the job done and get out”. It’s okay if they want to stop or take a break. I just wish they’d communicate that. Anyway, like most reviewers have said, listen pre-2020, but most after that aren’t worth it.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    Andrea62388
    Jun 17
    2

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    Let Down City

    This podcast used to be my favorite part of the week. I haven’t listened in months and just pulled them up again to find nothing but repeat episodes and these “quilts” we’ve all heard before. Make something new or just call it.

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
    Label
    mjg2067
    Jun 17
    10

    reviewed: My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

    SSDGM

    It’s all my favourite things in one podcast! This podcast has it all! From humour to horror and all the emotions in between, this group of wonderful murderinos (Karen, Georgia and STEVEN) take you with them as they deep dive into all of their favourite murder stories. This is truly my favourite murder podcast!

    Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
    0
521 Episodes 151k Ratings First Aired: Jan 14, 2016 🇺🇸

Lifelong fans of true crime stories Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark tell each other their favorite tales of murder and hear hometown crime stories from friends and fans.

Published by

People

Tagged with

Comedy
521 Episodes 151k Ratings First Aired: Jan 14, 2016 🇺🇸

Lifelong fans of true crime stories Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark tell each other their favorite tales of murder and hear hometown crime stories from friends and fans.

Published by

People

Tagged with

Comedy
0:00 0:00