MTGGoldfish Podcast

MTGGoldfish Podcast

Published by: MTGGoldfish
270 Episodes | First Released: Mar 30
Every week get an in-depth discussion behind the latest news in Magic the Gathering, focusing on finance, competitive deck building and budget brewing.
Label
El Galactico 723
May 2
Rating:   2
Richard ruins it

If you wanna listen to Richard (the owner of MTGGoldfish) complain and cry about magic the gathering for an hour every week this is the place to get your fix. For some reason you can also hear him slapping his gums when he talks I thought I was the only one until I saw a review mention it also. Crim is always great to listen to and I used to love this podcast overall but I’m tired of all the complaining and whining that’s constant.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Rashrader
Apr 13
Rating:   4
Too much of an Agenda for my taste....

I was all in and enjoying this podcast until they started calling for and predicting the death of paper Magic. I know, it was only one person. Regardless, I am certainly not going to support this sort of “End of the World” fanaticism. See you guys. Good Luck.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
moconfi
Mar 28
Rating:   10
Amazing 😉

I have gotten so much great information and entertainment from this great podcast! You guys are the best!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
mark wy
Mar 18
Rating:   10
Top notch!

If you only listen to one MTG podcast this should be it. Super current and interesting. Stay up to date with three people that have a deep relationship with MTG.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Dartymissile
Mar 17
Rating:   10
Good for casuals

If you are looking a nuanced look at the meta, and your a higher level player, not a good podcast for you. This is much more a podcast from the average joe perspective, which personally I enjoy because I don’t have the time or money for magic to be a serious hobby for me. They often talk about what they see on the internet, and if you frequently browse reddit and twitter, and watch out for magic news you won’t hear anything new. I personally want me news curated and don’t want to have to make an opinion for myself. To summarize, great for a casual player.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Dday2406
Mar 13
Rating:   4
Useful info but too lax

I appreciate having a good time or people making a good joke to laugh at but the hosts literally use laughter as communication mechanism because they can’t take themselves seriously. While I get that can be hard to get rid of that habit, it’s horrible to listen too when it’s over a third or half of the podcast.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
P4ras
Mar 10
Rating:   10
Amazing Podcast

I learn everything I need to know about Magic from this podcast, and helps me stay up to date on releases and changes

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Tarkelz
Feb 25
Rating:   10
A good friendcast

Seth, Crim and Richard keep up on MTG news, have good chemistry, and discuss a lot of things not found elsewhere in MTG podcasts. It's a weekly listen for me.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
bonferroni5e-8
Nov 11 '19
Rating:   10
Entertaining mtg podcast

Crime has been an excellent addition to the show! Him and SaffronOlive make it worthwhile listening.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
James tnt
Sep 8 '19
Rating:   10
Hi seth

First on June 10 episode :)

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
JakeyJ69
Jul 2 '19
Rating:   10
Ahhhhhh

Dude Richard ya gotta learn to talk into the mic. You keep slapping your gums and lips when you talk? Idk what it is but it’s annoying. 5 stars for Saf

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
TheCrookedCroc
Jun 5 '19
Rating:   4
It amazes me constantly how little they know for how entrenched they are in the community

Not very well informed. Maybe review show notes before the cast and actually do a little more research? Maybe that takes the fun/casualness out of it tho. (Crims cool though)

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
MTWMTG
May 29 '19
Rating:   8
Good for casuals, not worth for competitive

The discussion is good and better yet, really topical and consistent.However, the discussion will not help you win more and get an edge in competition because the hosts are either not playing (Richard) or medium at the game (Seth). Crim doesn’t really have the radio chops to add much to the podcast.Listen for fun, but don’t expect too much insight.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
max97212
Feb 25 '19
Rating:   6
Not quite as good as it used to be

Crim seems like a great guy, but the mix of him with the two regulars is dramatically worse than it was with Chris Van Meter.CVM provided a nice serious counterbalance to the main hosts. But now it’s all cringey nervous laughter as everyone literally laughs at their own jokes... or even at no joke at all. “That card is good hahahaha.” What?I’d love the podcasters to treat the show a little more seriously instead of recording some buddies chatting with each other and calling it a day.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
James tnt
Feb 20 '19
Rating:   10
Hi

Dear, Seth,Crim,Richard, and Tomer 2/19/2019Hello everyone it’s Seth probably better known as Safronolive. (Seth sorry if I spelt that 😂) best podcast ever Seth’s silliness and Richards filthy cashaule perspectiva and crims well... crim whatever his personality is??? Befor Mondays where always dreadful but when I found out about MTG Goldfish I was all in. It started when people at my legs stopped playing stand eres so I played modern and I watch agents the odds. Then I found out about commander clash for a long Time I was looking for something like game knights made by ( the command zone)! It so great that there are so many funny people in the world! Sincerely, Jace

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Benjamin Thi
Jan 29 '19
Rating:   8
Great content and evaluations but..

Can Crim complete a single sentence without chuckling? It’s actually distracting how often he laughs.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
JeskaiMage
Jan 10 '19
Rating:   8
Chimney imp is playable in pauper!!!

Meme cards can be good!!!I’m writing too many exclamation points!!!

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
The Great Carbuncle
Aug 28 '18
Rating:   10
Girlfriend approved

These folks are so entertaining that my wife loves to listen even though she has a mere cursory knowledge of Magic: the Gathering. P.S. Erin is her favorite. Also, when is the Newsening returning. Three guys seriously. Thanks y’all.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
Mike Noble
Aug 21 '18
Rating:   4
Mickey Mouse Narrates Reddit

I used to find a lot of useful information and discussion in this podcast. The hosts have a younger look at the game, and their lack of experience used to bring a fresher perspective rather than an air of niaveté. However, as of late, the introduction of CVM has made it crystal clear that the other hosts are not currently cut out for an accurate nor interesting portrayal of the week’s news. CVM is a saint, bringing Richard and Seth back on track while they squawk about the same garbage Reddit topics that have been rehashed a thousand times. After listening to this week’s episode, it’s become abundantly clear that an episode without CVM is an episode without integrity. Do some research, both on journalistic integrity and finding less Buzzfeed-style headlines, and the podcast can get back on track.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
Label
NorcrossDad
Jun 14 '18
Rating:   10
Awesome, awesome podcast!

HELLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLO EVERYONE, IT’S SETH. PRAHBABLY BETTER KNOWN AS SAFFRONOLIVE.Seriously though- this podcast is wonderful and fantastic for any Magic players looking for a great listen discussing everything MTG.

Reviewed on Apple Podcasts
0:00 / 0:00